Wrestling Ticket Stub Buyers
WrestleMania, the territory days, Madison Square Garden cards and local arena shows. WWF, NWA, AWA and promotions long since gone. Send photos and I will tell you what each one is worth.
WWF, Madison Square Garden
What wrestling stubs sell for
Real offers I have made in the last year. Condition, rarity and the event itself all move the number, so treat this as a rough guide rather than a price list.
WrestleMania I - 1985
Madison Square Garden
$500 - $1,500+
Early WrestleMania tickets
WrestleMania II-VI era
$100 - $500+
Historic debut / championship matches
Hogan, Undertaker, Rock, Austin and other
major stars
$50 - $500+
1980s WWF Madison Square Garden events
Hogan-era house shows and televised events
$10 - $75+
1990s-2000s common WWF/WWE
Regular events and bulk collections
$2 - $15 each
Disclaimer: These are examples, not a price list. The value of a ticket can vary dramatically based on the event, date, rarity, condition, whether it is a full ticket or stub, and other factors. Even tickets from ordinary games or concerts can sometimes be valuable because of something historic that happened that day. Send us photos of your collection and we'll research it for free.
What makes a wrestling stub valuable
Four things, roughly in order of how much they matter.
The card
A title change, a famous match or a first appearance is what collectors look for.
The promotion
Territory promotions sold far fewer tickets than the national shows, so fewer stubs survive.
The venue
Madison Square Garden, the Boston Garden and the old regional arenas all draw interest.
Full ticket or stub
A ticket never torn at the door is scarcer than the stub half, sometimes by a wide margin.
Also happy to look at
Programs, ringside passes, closed-circuit tickets for big events shown in theatres, and cards from promotions that no longer exist.
Closed-circuit tickets are rare and often overlooked. If yours names a theatre instead of an arena, send it.
1931 World Series, Shibe Park
Robert Araghi Review
Robert Araghi
What sellers say
4.9 average from 120 Trustpilot reviews
"Very straight-forward and upfront business. Dave was very respondent and so easy to work with. Will definitely be contacting him again if and when I discover another 'hidden treasure'!!"
Walter Church
"Smooth Transaction. Will do business again. Entire transaction could not have gone better. Great response time, great communication, and great results."
Juke
"Dave was a pleasure to work with! He responded very quickly with an offer and sent payment just as fast! I would definitely sell to him again!"
Ryan Stoor
Chris
Chris Review
Wrestling questions I get asked
Are closed-circuit tickets worth anything?
Often more than the arena tickets from the same night, because so few were printed and kept.
My stub is from a small local show.
Send it. Local territory cards are exactly what a lot of collectors are trying to find.
What about tickets signed by wrestlers?
A signature can add value, but it depends on who signed and whether it can be trusted. Send a clear photo and I will tell you what I think.
Ready to find out what yours are worth?
Send a few photos and I’ll come back with a number. No fees, no obligation.