Are my old video games worth anything?

Thinking about selling your old video games? If phrases like “blow on the cartridge and pray” or “memory card full” ring a bell, there’s a good chance those games in your attic, closet, or storage bin could be worth real money.

At Dave Buys Ticket Stubs (DBTS), we don’t just buy ticket stubs—we also buy vintage and retro video games, consoles, and accessories. If you’re sorting through an old collection (yours or a family member’s), we’ll make it easy, safe, and fast to get a fair cash offer.

•  Yes, old video games can be valuable. Especially complete-in-box (CIB), factory sealed, limited releases, cult classics, and low-print titles.
•  Loose games and used consoles still sell. Don’t toss them—we buy them.
•  Two easy ways to get an offer:
  1. Send photos for a same-day quote, or
  2. Use our mail-in option (insured USPS label—no photos needed).

If you see these names, pay attention. We buy them all:

•  Nintendo: NES, SNES, Nintendo 64, GameCube, Wii, Game Boy / Color / Advance, DS, 3DS
•  Sega: Genesis (Mega Drive), Saturn, Dreamcast, Game Gear
•  Sony: PlayStation (PS1), PS2, PS3 (select titles), PSP, PS Vita
•  Microsoft: Original Xbox, Xbox 360 (select titles)
•  Classics & Cult: Atari 2600/5200/7800, TurboGrafx-16/PC Engine, Neo Geo (AES/MVS), 3DO, ColecoVision, Intellivision

Pro tip: Handhelds (Game Boy line, PSP, Vita) and obscure add-ons (Sega CD/32X, N64 Expansion Pak, RF Switches, OEM controllers) can add surprising value.

Condition matters, but it’s not everything. Collectors still buy played copies if the title is desirable.

•  Completeness: Original box, manual, inserts, maps, registration cards
•  Condition: Clean labels, no disc rot, minimal scratches, working saves
•  Rarity & Demand: Low-print runs, cult classics, region exclusives, “Not For Resale” variants
•  Version Matters: 
  •  PS1 “black label” often beats “Greatest Hits”
  •  Nintendo “Player’s Choice” vs. standard print can differ in value
  •  Early prints / misprints / hang-tabs can be sleepers
•  Sealed & Graded: Factory-sealed or professionally graded games can command premiums (we buy those too)

Not a price list—just a feel for the kinds of titles that get attention.

•  SNES: EarthBound, Chrono Trigger, Mega Man X series
•  N64: The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time (Collector’s Edition), Conker’s Bad Fur Day, Paper Mario
•  PS1: Final Fantasy VII (black label), Castlevania: Symphony of the Night, Suikoden II
•  Game Boy: Pokémon Red/Blue/Yellow (CIB), Shantae (GBC)
•  Genesis/Saturn/Dreamcast: Musha (Genesis), Panzer Dragoon Saga (Saturn), Marvel vs. Capcom 2 (Dreamcast)

Bottom line: Age ≠ value. But low supply + high nostalgia often does.

We’ve helped thousands of people turn collections into cash with a safe, no-pressure process. Choose what’s easiest:

1. Lay games flat in group photos of ~20–30 items per pic (fronts; add backs/discs if easy).
2. Include close-ups of notable titles and anything boxed/sealed.
3. Text or email photos to us (details below).
4. Get a same-day cash offer. If you accept, we pay first (PayPal, Venmo, Zelle, or Check) and we cover shipping.

1. Tell us roughly what you have (systems, # of games).
2. We email you an insured, expedited USPS label, no photography required.
3. Pack safely, add padding, and drop at the Post Office (or hand to your carrier).
4. We review within 24 hours of arrival and send a fair cash offer.
   •  Accept? We pay immediately.
   •  Decline? We ship everything back at our expense.

We operate nationwide, remotely, and safely. You’ll always know where your items are and when you’ll be paid.

While we’re famous for preserving ticket stubs, we also buy:

•  Retro & vintage video games, consoles, accessories
•  Ticket stubs & programs (sports, concerts, events)
•  Sports cards & memorabilia
•  Comics & original art
•  Autographs & original photos
•  Vintage toys & action figures
•  Coins & currency
•  Movie/TV/music memorabilia & posters

If it lives at the intersection of nostalgia and history, there’s a good chance we’re interested.

•  Keep sets together: Bundles (console + controllers + cables + memory cards) are buyer-friendly.
•  Don’t scrub labels: Over-cleaning can do more harm than good.
•  Include extras: Strategy guides, maps, demo discs, kiosks/promos, store displays, tell us if you have them!
•  Original receipts or provenance can help on special items.

Reach out today for a no-pressure cash offer:

•  Text/Call: (312) 402-1371
•  Email: Dave@DaveBuysTicketStubs.com
•  Or use the contact form on our website.

We’ll help you sort the sleepers from the shelf-sitters—and make the whole thing easy, safe, and fast.

Do you buy loose cartridges or discs with scratches?

Yes. Loose games are fine. Light disc wear is common; we still evaluate everything.

Will you buy my whole lot, or only the best titles?

Either. We buy full collections, select highlights, or both—whatever works for you.

What about factory-sealed or graded games?

We purchase sealed and professionally graded items as well as CIB and loose copies.

How fast do I get paid?

If you accept our offer, payment is same-day via PayPal, Venmo, Zelle, or Check.

Is shipping really covered?

Yep. We cover inbound and (if needed) return shipping. Our mail-in option includes an insured USPS label.

Do you only buy in Chicago?

We’re nationwide. Most deals are completed remotely in a few easy steps.

Do you buy modern games?

We focus on vintage and retro, but we’ll happily review your list and include modern titles that make sense.